Shuart no more: Cosmos forced elsewhere for Open Cup matches

Last year, the Cosmos won one of the most exciting matches in their short reboot history, forcing 120 minutes of soccer and penalty kicks with NYCFC. But from the jaws of victory, the Cosmos also took away a defeat. 

On a call Thursday, Cosmos COO Erik Stover disclosed information that may impact the home field advantage the Cosmos have often relied on, especially in their Open Cup matches.

“We’ve been told by Hofstra we cannot host any MLS teams in the Open Cup at Shuart stadium,” explained Stover. “We’ve spent quite a bit of time trying to change their mind over that decision and unfortunately we haven’t been able to do that.”

“Most of it was from last year. There were some altercations and some incidences of thefts of scarves and hats and things. A fair amount of complaints to the university from patrons of the event,” he added. “We haven’t had any security issues really in the three plus seasons we’ve played there, except last season at the NYCFC game.”

While Belson is a very small facility, other challenges have presented themselves with other potential venues often discussed by the public when talking about temporary stadium options.

“MCU [Park] is an issue with the field. There were complaints in the two games we played there with the different colored turfs with the brown baseball infield and the green outfield.”

Stover refers to the regular season match against Ottawa and the playoff semifinal against the Strikers held there in 2015.

Mitchell Field was also ruled out by the club.

“That field is totally unacceptable to play a professional soccer game on.  The quality of the turf is an issue. And then when you add football lines, lacrosse lines, logos, everything makes it almost impossible from a competitive standpoint to think that that would be acceptable. And then the last thing is that facility is booked solid almost the entire year, so date availability is a big challenge.”

Citifield was also brought up and promptly dismissed.

“Some people talk about going to Citifield. There’s numerous scheduling challenges throughout the Open Cup tournament. But also, it’s cost-prohibitive. You saw last night, there were about 4000 people in Fordham.”

One of the biggest issues, however, are the rules of hosting an Open Cup match, which require the host to have a facility locked down well in advance of knowing who their opponent might be.

“The application process with US Soccer requires you to confirm dates well in advance, and venues. At those times, you don’t know who your opponents are and if you don’t have your own stadium that has reliable dates, then we find ourselves in a situation like this.”

Which has brought the Cosmos back to Belson.

“Our venue for the application process through US Soccer has been Belson Stadium throughout and we’re confident that the stadium for the Revolution game will be adequate. We’ll see what happens if we advance on, what the best course of action will be for the next round should again we advance and depending on who we host. So, irregardless of how far we go through the tournament, Belson will need to be our home stadium.”

Belson’s official capacity is listed at 2,600 although it can accommodate up to 5,000. Which brings up the question of how long the Cosmos could continue to host there.


Visit for the full post.

2 Responses

  1. DanRodriguez804

    Good job, Luis. I look forward to updates and I’ll have to check out your podcast. What I don’t get is in another article this guy touted that NexxTurf stuff. Couldn’t you put that over the turf at MCU and problem solved? Armada and NYCFC are able to make the field one color and it can’t be worse than all the confusing field demarcations at Hofstra. I can’t tell what’s what on that field.

    It’s a shame that there’s still no word on the stadium plan but at this point you’ve got to start looking at plan B. What would be a good plan B? I know Brooklyn borough president said he wants them but I can’t see a project of that size near public transportation. Maybe a scaled down version in Coney Island.

  2. DanRodriguez804

    If they’re gonna play in a 5,000 stadium, why not make it exciting (albeit a bitch to get to) and play at Icahn stadium on Randalls Island?

Social Media Auto Publish Powered By :